I am searching for a good concealer/highlighter because I've always had very dark circles under my eyes, as well as crepiness in the undereye skin. Based on the 5 star reviews, I was hopeful this pencil would work for me. I found it to be not very creamy, it dragged when applying and ever though it blended okay, it settled into my lines, without provided best coverage. A new product is always worth a try, but unfortunately, this went back to HSN.