HSN Customer Ratings and Reviews
Bath & Body(4,163)
Beauty Tools & Accessories(1,030)
Fragrance(843)
Hair Care(5,904)
Makeup(8,342)
Blush(217)
Bronzers(292)
Eyeshadows(204)
Foundation & Powder(2,592)
Lancôme Mascara(238)
Lipsticks(192)
Mascaras(1,130)
More Makeup(31)
Primers and Concealers(1,275)
Spray On Makeup(136)
Personal Care & Spa(374)
Skin Care(17,202)
Skin Tighteners(12)
Sun Care(518)
Shop Now At HSN
Shop Mascaras or
Choose a Category
- American Glamour Badgley Mischka
- Back to Campus
- Beauty Products
- Chi by Falchi
- Collectibles
- Collectibles Specials
- Crafts & Sewing
- Curations
- Customer Picks
- Dads & Grads
- Electronics
- Electronics Promotions
- Email Marketing
- Entertainment
- Fashion Promotions
- For the Home
- Free Shipping
- Garnet Hill
- Gemstone Finder
- Gift Cards
- HSN Birthday Store
- Healthy Choices
- Holiday Gifts
- Home Decor
- Home Solutions
- Host Picks
- House & Home Specials
- IMAN Global Chic
- Infomercial
- Intimate Apparel
- Jewelry
- Kids' Store
- Kitchen & Dining
- Limited Inventory
- Men's Shop
- Mother's Day Gifts
- New Arrivals
- Paula Abdul
- Personalized Gifts
- PriceBusters
- Sale & Clearance
- Serena Williams
- Social Occasions
- Special Promotions
- Sports
- Summer Entertaining
- Summer Shop
- Sunrise Host Picks
- Today on HSN
- Toy Store
- Valentine's Day
- Wedding
- Wellness
- Women's Fashion
- Women's Shoes and Handbags
customer picks - our top rated products
Product Reviews
MAKE UP FOR EVER Smoky Lash Extra Black Mascara
Product Reviews
MAKE UP FOR EVER Smoky Lash Extra Black Mascara
Avg. Customer Rating
Let MAKE UP FOR EVER help you create true fashionista fringe with the Smoky Lash Extra Black Mascara. Designed to give you sexy, smoldering eyes, this ultra-pigmented mascara delivers a fabulous faux lash effect. You receive a generously-sized .23 oz. mascara. MAKE UP FOR EVER Smoky Lash Extra Black Mascara Features: Elastomer high-density brush with fibers that reach the roots for exceptional separation of your lashes. Delivers a length and curl effect. Fragrance-free formula contains panthenol pro-vitamin B5. Contains black mineral pigments for an intense black look with optimum volume. Made in France.
Customer Reviews for MAKE UP FOR EVER Smoky Lash Extra Black Mascara
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
/ Anonymous ,
WORST MASCARA EVER!
/ Anonymous ,
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
Date: 04/13/2009
This is the worst mascara ever! It DOES add volume, if you like your eyelashes to be clumpy!!! I'm not sending it back because I don't want to pay the shipping, but this was a huge waste of money. I'm so disappointed!
1 of 1 found this review helpful.
Share this review:
Review 2 for MAKE UP FOR EVER Smoky Lash Extra Black Mascara
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
/ Jessica ,
Location: VA
BEST EVER!!
/ Jessica ,
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
Date: 04/01/2009
Ladies, this for me is hands down the best mascara I have ever used. I will NOT be without it!!!!
Share this review:
Review 3 for MAKE UP FOR EVER Smoky Lash Extra Black Mascara
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
/ Talulah ,
Location: WI
Great mascara except for flaking
/ Talulah ,
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
Date: 02/27/2009
Am I the only one who experienced flaking from this? Other than the ongoing flaking ending up below my eyes, it is great! For once a fragrance free that doesn't make me allergic but it doesn't help if it won't stay on!
Share this review:
Review 4 for MAKE UP FOR EVER Smoky Lash Extra Black Mascara
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
/ CONSTANCE ,
REALLY BLACK
/ CONSTANCE ,
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
Date: 01/01/2009
I JUST HAD TO WRITE A REVIEW, BECAUSE THIS MASCARA DESERVES MORE THAN PEOPLE ARE GIVING IT. IT IS VERY RICH AND BLACK WHERE YOU DON'T REALLY NEED A EYELINER IF YOU CHOOSE. THE BRUSH IS PERFECT WHERE IT FINDS REALLY THE SMALLEST OF EYELASHES AND I KNOW BECAUSE I BARELY HAVE EYELASHES UNTIL I USE THIS MASCARA, AND IT DON'T SNUDGE.
Share this review:
Review 5 for MAKE UP FOR EVER Smoky Lash Extra Black Mascara
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
/ MOBHDG ,
Location: MD
Great -- more coverage than Dior
/ MOBHDG ,
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
Date: 12/15/2008
This mascara is great. It's super black and the brush gets every little lash. I did one application, and a few minutes later did another quick coat. And that lasted all day, no smudging. I am huge fan of Dior mascara, but I am switching to this mascara. Dior dries out too easily.
Share this review:
Review 6 for MAKE UP FOR EVER Smoky Lash Extra Black Mascara
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
/ Anonymous ,
Don''t waste your money
/ Anonymous ,
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
Date: 12/09/2008
TOO CLUMPY - Not worth it. Going back!
Share this review:
Review 7 for MAKE UP FOR EVER Smoky Lash Extra Black Mascara
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
/ Anonymous ,
Location: NY
Wow!!!
/ Anonymous ,
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
Date: 11/24/2008
I've been using the same name brand mascara for the past 30 years. From time to time I've tried others but nothing worked as well and I thought nothing ever would. When I got this I had no great expectations but thought it was worth a try after seeing the demonstration. Was I ever surprised. This stuff is incredible. In one deft stroke my lashes went from virtually invisible to downright glamorous. I'll definitely be back for more.
Share this review:
Review 8 for MAKE UP FOR EVER Smoky Lash Extra Black Mascara
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
/ Michele ,
Location: PA
SAVE YOUR MONEY
/ Michele ,
Average Customer Rating:
out of
5
Date: 11/24/2008
This is NOT worth $22 (plus s/h)! I could have gone to the drugstore and bought a mascara with better results. The mascara came out in little 'globs' that stuck to my lashes. I thought maybe my touch was wrong, so washed it off and tried again. The same thing happened. You get 'pieces' stuck on your lashes and instead of nice separated lashes, they also get stuck together.
This is the worst mascara I've ever tried. Should I return it? I'll probably just toss it!
This is the worst mascara I've ever tried. Should I return it? I'll probably just toss it!
Share this review:
