I just got this product and I put it on and did all my make-up and I am positively thrilled with the color of the eyeliner, or pencil, and the easy application, and when set there is no smudging. I love it' i'm going to order 2 more. For the women who's pencils broke the liner. just put the eye pencil in the frig for a minute and it won't break so easy. Thank you for this product...