I tried several colors, sizes, etc- the hips and /or waist were good on some- not so good on others - and, the thighs too big on most! Very frustrating!!! If they weren't on sale and made so well I would have given up. I ended up with a 14 chambray.
I prefer a darker wash but I couldn't get the 14 indigo even close to fitting. And the 16 indigo were way too big!
4 stars for the overall quality of these jeans, but I took one star off for the sizing issues.