I rated these fair because of the sizing. I love these shoes, but both pairs I ordered, one was taupe in size 11 wide for my mother, and the other was orange in size 9 wide for myself, have to be returned because they are much too large.
The leather is a very good quality, the look is smart, they will be very comfortable. I need them for a trip, so I am going to re-order them and pay again, as I have not been able to return them yet and the exchange will not happen in time.