I love the lip gloss, it stays on a very long time, and the colors are really lovely. The bronzer is nice, not too dark. I am still not sure on the mascara, it's really gloppy, or at the least the tubes I got are. I think it would be really good mascara, but a ton of it comes out on the wand, so I get really gloopy lashes. Othere than that, a really nice kit for the money.