THE GOOD: the suede is butter soft, the shaft is large enough to fit around someone who is more than a stick figure. You get two different looks when detaching the suede piece and wearing the bootie alone (bonus). If you buy the black and any color, you can attach the black suede piece onto the bottoms of any color to create a colorblock look. GREAT DESIGN!
THE BAD: Because of the inside fabric, you must wear hose, tights or tucked in pants - bare legs will stick and make it very difficult to get the boots off. I would like to have seen a better quality back zipper on the bootie -- mine sticks. Also would have been nice if the zippers were nylon and color matched so they would be more concealed.
TIP: you must undo the zipper going down the BACK of the bootie in order to get the boot on and off.